Shared Knowledge

 

Slingbox AV

 

15 June 2007

Updated: 11 July 2007 

 

 

 

It is my own fault for not doing more research before I jumped, but when I received my Slingbox via UPS and took a look at the box, I could not believe that it had an Ethernet port on the back and not either a USB port for a USB WIFI connection or better yet, built in WIFI. Ethernet?

 

How many people have an Ethernet cable beside their cable box or Tivo?

 

Oh, but the Slingbox people are ready with an answer. For another $100, you can buy from them a power line Ethernet connection. One end connects to the Slingbox and power beside the Slingbox and the other end connects to an Ethernet router and the power line near the router. Now according to Slingbox, this is a 100MBPS link, which is fine and dandy but my cable modem only uploads 512KBPS maximum so a 100MBPS link really does not buy me anything over going with a 802.1G WIFI Bridge at 54MBPS and I have had very mixed results in the past with sending signals over the power lines in a house.

 

Now once I got my Slingbox working with a new Dlink Ethernet to WiFi box (getting the Dlink to talk with my network is another story altogether), Slingbox software could not automatically adjust my Linksys router to allow for remote access, so I had to manually go into the Linksys and set up a port for Slingbox to use. This was not difficult as I have been into the Linksys software before and even knew where to set up the port for Slingbox, but for some, this is not a walk in the park and certainly not plug and play.

 

Now with the Slingbox software installed on my laptop, I started the Slingbox player and did see the control for Tivo but had trouble getting any of the Tivo control buttons to respond to my mouse clicks. The problem, of course, is with the position, placement of the Slingbox IR emitters. I hate these things, these IR emitters. Dam glue on them just not hold the emitters in place and getting them just right is also a pain. Anyway, finally, I got the emitters in place correctly and could control my Tivo box from the Slingbox player application. Please note that controlling a Tivo via Slingbox Tivo control simulation is frustratingly slow. I have found that if you have Slingbox set to optimize the data stream, clicking the buttons on the Tivo controller, may or many not work. Turning off the optimize setting does help the situation but even if you click and hold a Tivo control button down, it can take several seconds for the actual Tivo to respond!

 

Now as to video received via the Slingbox player, on my old 877MHZ, 256MB of memory laptop, I have had to reduce the quality of the Slingbox stream to have any sort of video, which is not choppy. This, however, is not a problem on my main computer, which is running at 3GHZ, 2GB of memory but how many folks are going to be lugging a 3GHZ desktop around?

 

The Slingbox player requirements state a 1GHZ processor or better and I think they do mean what they say. Slingbox will run on a slower machine, but with reduced video quality.

 

Ethernet? How much more could it have cost to build in WIFI?

 

Oh, I contacted Slingbox about the Ethernet port business and there response was that 70% of their users locate their cable modem and router right at the Slingbox and television. Perhaps this is so, when a house hold has only wireless laptops but would be a royal pain for me with 3 desktops going 24\7 in my office, all tied to my router via Ethernet cable. 

 

Update: 11 July 2007:

 

Took my Slingbox software equipped laptop with me on a recent trip to Spain. Via a wireless "B", 11 MBPS, Internet connection, Slingbox came up right away and worked as it had at home, except for the fact that the audio preceeded the video by some 2 or 3 seconds. To fix this problem, I moved the Slingbox performance setting to the full right or maximum bandwidth and processor requirements.

 

After using Slingbox successfully for 2 days, for some reason I forget now, I deceided to play around with Slingbox settings and during a Audio\Visual setup, aborted and then could never get the Slingbox software to find my Slingbox again. When I got home, I reset the Slingbox and all was well. My point here is that do not play with Slingbox settings remotely as settings adjustment may require a manual reset of Slingbox.